Do we really need paragraph 6 of the storms?

For over 50 years, predictors are addressed at the National Storm and used the Saffir-Simpson Hurricane storms to distinguish storm energy. This rate, which sets storms from paragraph 1 to section 5, based on only one metric highlight: higher higher air speed.

Not so. Until 2012, Shssws also take the medium and storm pressure, but the NHC finished these items to reduce social confusion. The problem is this, the global warming levels increases many of the storm risks, not just a spirit. In recent years, highest storms, such as Milton, Patricia, and Typhoon Haiyan, have aroused the argument that it is time to create paragraph 6.

In this giz he asks, ask us many experts with that comments. While some are unitedly, they are all agreed that simply adding Stage 6 to Shws are not an answer – although the previous few storms have passed 5 air speeds. Instead, some say that putting storm dangers in the heat world may need transfusions completely, while others believe that the existing plan should be changed.

Jennifer Collins

Professor at the Geoscience School at the University of South Florida has grown in other shsws.

Current SHSWs – as the word means – is only from the spirit. For this scale, my thoughts in paragraphs 6 is that we do not need when section 5 from what is attributes can lead to complete destruction. There was a lot of discussion in the scientific community in the past scientific scientific, and I believe that being the General Consensus.

Our newly proposed scales, StipClone Special Scale (TCSS), viewing that air often costs 10% of the massacre. Stormord Susfe Account approximately 50% of the rain on about 30%. Our scale includes all three Hurricane risks, we share each paragraph between 1 and 5. Then, it provides a whole class that we will never be under the highest stage given to accidents.

Example, Hurricane Florence in 2018 will be cat 1 to the worldwide deep, cat 4 storm surgery, and 5 icy rain. Therefore, its complete amount will be cat 5 people underestimate the risk of low storms, or even a hot storm, when they look at their outcome, according to my former research.

The proposed TCSS also shows high risk of existing two or more accidents. We look at the biggest risk of risk when its class is classified as 3 or more (equivalent to the meaning of a big storm in shsws). At least two main risks have the same phase and the third risk is a low section, this explosion of the Stricase SIP phase at 1.

Thus, a large tropical storm can be separated as a 6th cat in TCSS in two cases. At least two accidents are the cat 5s, or two accidents are the cat 4s and one cat 5. This is meant to warn the storm society about many extreme society.

Brian Mc Noldyy

The high study associates at the University of Miami’s Rosenntiel of Marine, Nomospheric, and Earth Science followed and written on the Atlantic Atlantic Act since 1996.

My general thought is that adding 6 cat is not required and will not any current information value of information out there.

Since 1980, 5 cat storms are numbered about 5% of all named storms around the world. Atlantic directly, count 4%. I’m not sure that partition of the small amount of hurricanes is small drums and even any benefits.

The deepest storm of Atlantic on Allen’s record was Allen in 1980, with high-maximum number of 190 miles per hour. Nobody reached it from that sign. If a cat’s limit is at least 63-ter-ge winds as proposed in this study, for example, Atlantic storms until now he may qualify.

In addition, to divide those small amounts in small areas even to change the risk communication. The Nation Center Explains the 5 Aftermath of a 5 such as: “Damage is a disaster, high trees will be separated by the lasting churches.

What further communication in the risk can be present at section 6 if one should beep?

Liz Ritchie-Tyo

Professor Monash of Monash University’s School of Earth, atmosphere and environmental attraction as Deputy Director of Arc’s 21-century Climate Climate Higher Higher Climate Health Center.

The answer is “No.”

Shwws developed in the US is a storm expert and spiritual engineers to place higher air levels at the levels of land damage. When a storm is cat 5 in Shsss, that means disaster risk is expected. Therefore, the “new cat 6 is unreasonable by contacting threatening levels.

All programs for the storms of the storm of all the hottest storms are based on the highest air speed. Whether the Northern Pacific and North Pacific, or another scale in northern Pacific Pacific, the largest storm, if a severe storm reaches the maximum phase, disaster risk is possible when a storm made location.

The main limitation of the current division programs are not enough to increase sufficient linking, that they are excluded from the airway, which you do not have any potential dangers associated with the storm of the death of the world.

What we need to really need the “multi-pector” new system that cannot communicate with a lot of risks, that is the wind, a storm abuse, rain, floods and earthquakes. In accordance with the fall of land, the different risks will be very important. Onshore coastal, wind, waves, and storm surgery is very important, while floods and mortar and mortar caused by large rain is very important in the world.

In addition, the high-backing air speed does not receive the Storm-Force Aarial ratios create waves and surgery. A bigger place for these spirits harm, it is a major effect of storm surgery. Similarly, the intensity of the great wind is not right in line with heavy rain. Although it is true that cat 4 and 5 storms produce large rainfall, cat 1 hurricanes can produce large rain.

Therefore, a program to classify features with Platypo-Factors that cannot communicate with various accidents will be more useful than adding additional category on the current scale.

Daniel Brown, the chief of the NHC Hurricane Branch

The branch officer of the NHC Hurricane branch. In this passage, he looks at a unit that releases the tropical storm predictions and Atlantic warnings and east of the northern Pacific Hurricane Barrins.

Currently, there is no ongoing attempts within noaa to convert Shss or add a new paragraph 6.

The storms of the storm are only contacted with the spirit risk. When you warn the public about tropical issues, the National Storm Center communicates with many accidents, including storm surgery, air, rain, storms and rain muscles.

We do not extremely emphasize the spirit of the spirit by putting the focus of the paragraph, because more deaths caused by hot storms is due to a water accident. Storm surgery, rain and floods in the country, and a dangerous surf causes about 90% hot storms of hot stormies in the US

In addition, the Saffir-Simperson Scale Scale section is already underesting the worst damage, led as a “catastrophic injury.” No matter the storms are strong, the damage cannot get worse than “disaster.”

Mark Bourassa

The Meteorology State University Center learns about seawater in the aircraft in the interaction of air / oceans, and tropical storms, and the construction of tropical storms.

A person can make the best debate and improved measurements that will allow us to divide storms like cat 5, but will help for any reason no more than a record containing more detailed record?

I find any biggest storm that we have doubted that I doubt the new section will contribute to social reactions. People who are unable or unable to exit the cat 3 or 4 will usually not be able or able to get out of a strong storm or.

There are certain types of information predictions that are trying to communicate well, and this is more useful than describing a new storm section. The weather maps in Storm Surge is one example of the development that affects the risk of Hurricane.

I hope to see clear messages about the conflict of different winds that reach my place where I live and work. I had also accepted more information on the flood. This information will be much useful than distorting between cat 5 and cat 6 storm, community and emergency management.

That means, the arguments I make by building a cat 6 are not especially good because such unity policy seems to be stored rather than provide more information. There is no reason that we cannot pursue all these options, but we talk as a person living near the Gulf Coast coast, I would like better Profitic Top.